Divorce Lawyer Reveals Why Quiet Marriages Fall Apart After 50, and Why Date Night Can't Save Them
We never fought. We just ran out of things to say. A divorce lawyer showed me what was really going on, and the simple game book that put the noise back in our house (without another date night, another big talk or counseling).
"Mom, are you and Dad okay? You two barely said ten words to each other all day."
My daughter said that last Thanksgiving, on her way out the door with the leftovers. She wasn't being mean. She was right.
That night, after he went up to bed at ten to ten, I sat at the kitchen table and worked out, on the back of a grocery list, which one of us would keep the house.
We used to stay up talking until the late news. Now we passed each other like two polite roommates. Nobody cheated. Nobody yelled. He's never once raised his voice at me.
My sister told me to have the big talk, so I did. He listened to every word. Then for six weeks he did everything I asked, and every bit of it felt like a man doing a chore.
So I booked a consultation with a divorce lawyer. Just to know.
If your marriage is kind, quiet and empty after dinner, and nothing you've tried has changed it, pay close attention to this next part.
What Is "The Empty Hour"? (And Why Divorce After 50 Has Doubled)
She's handled more than 600 divorces. She listened for ten minutes. Then she asked, "Carol, what do the two of you do with the other three hours, every single night?"
She called it the empty hour. It's the stretch between dinner and bed once the kids are gone, when the TV goes on and the phones come out.
The divorce rate after 50 has doubled since 1990.Β² Nearly 4 in 10 people getting divorced now are 50 or older.ΒΉ She sees them every week. "It's not a fight," she said. "It's not that you fell out of love. And it's not your fault. Nothing happens in that room, night after night, so it fills itself."
Why Date Night, the Big Talk and Counseling Keep Letting You Down
- The big talk. He heard me. Then it turned into a chore list.
- Date nights. Four Fridays in a row. We ran out of things to say before the bread came.
- Question card decks. One reviewer called a popular one "homework." Ours went in a drawer after his first "I don't know."
- Counseling. A kind man with good questions. Then we drove home and sat in the same two chairs.
Every one of them asked us to talk more. None of them touched the empty hour.
It's Not a Talking Problem. It's an Evening Problem.
She pulled out a yellow legal pad and wrote seven steps. The kids leave. Dinner gets shorter. The TV goes on. The phones come out. One of you goes to bed first. Then somebody books a date night. Then date night stops working, and somebody calls her.
"Most couples only ever fix step six," she said, tapping the date night. "But the TV, the phones and the early bedtime happen every single night. Date night isn't wrong. It just fixes the wrong hour."
The Strange Book a Divorce Lawyer Keeps in Her Desk Drawer
Then she opened her desk drawer. "The couples who walk out of here and tear up the papers almost never fixed the talking. They found something to do together. And it has to have a winner."
She set a book on the desk. It's called Games & Us, a book of two-player games, and that's all it is. A game? I nearly laughed. "Will he actually play it?"
"Give a man a point to win off his wife," she said, "and watch how fast the phone goes down. I gave one to my own husband last winter. He lost three rounds and demanded a rematch."
What's Inside Games & Us: Two Players, a Score and a Champion
There's no advice in it, and not one question about feelings. Every game is two players, face to face, with a score.
How Well Do You Know Me? is the one that gets everybody. You each write your answers, then guess the other's, a point for every one you get right. Confess or Forever Hold Your Peace is two truths and a lie, with a point every time you catch him.
The Mystery Cipher gives you two minutes to crack a secret code. Lose the Scavenger Duel and you owe three compliments, out loud. Quick-fire duels, riddles and drawing battles fill the rest, and the last page crowns a champion.
One page after dinner. Two pens. About twenty minutes. Nothing to set up and no rules to learn. You open it, read the challenge out loud, and go.
Check Availability Β»
Putting It to the Test (He Rolled His Eyes)
It showed up about two weeks later. I put it on the table after dinner. He rolled his eyes. Then he picked up the pen.
Night one: How Well Do You Know Me? He got three. He argued across the table about whether my favorite sandwich counts if he got the bread right. I laughed so hard I had to take my glasses off.
Week one: at ten to ten, he didn't go up to bed. He turned the page.
Week three: we skipped a few nights when the grandkids visited, and the quiet crept right back. So now it's one page after dinner, every night.
Last Sunday our daughter called. She heard us fighting over a riddle in the background and said, "Wait. Are you two playing a game?"
What Makes Games & Us So Different From Date Night?
| Games & Us | Date night | Question cards | Counseling | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fills the evening at home | β | β | β | β |
| Nothing to "discuss" | β | β | β | β |
| Somebody wins | β | β | β | β |
| He'll ask for a rematch | β | β | β | β |
| Any night, no sitter or reservation | β | β | β | β |
Where Can I Get Games & Us?
It's sold online, straight from the publisher, and it sells out from time to time. About 3 in 10 orders are for more than one copy, a second one for a sister, a daughter or a friend. Tap below to check today's stock.
Check Availability Β»
Backed by a 30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
If you two don't play it, send it back within 30 days and get every penny back. No questions, no hard feelings.
How Many More Quiet Evenings Will You Sit Through?
You can keep doing what we did. Dinner, the TV, two chairs, and one of you goes up first. Nobody leaves over a fight. People leave over a Tuesday.
Or you can put a book on the table tonight and hand him a pen, with 30 days to decide. Thanksgiving is a few weeks away. Picture your kids walking in to the two of you laughing over a scorecard, instead of sitting in two chairs.
I bought a second copy for my daughter. Ours has our handwriting all the way through it.
Check Availability Β»
What Other Couples Are Saying
Alyssa M. β Verified buyer
"Better than a date night out" No sitter, no reservation, no $80 dinner where we both look at our phones. Same laughs for the price of a book.
Marcus T. β Verified buyer
"Finally something that isnβt a βtalkβ" My wife has bought us three of those question books. This is the first one I actually wanted to open, because thereβs a score.
Danielle R. β Verified buyer
"We played four pages the first night" Meant to do one. He got competitive on the guessing round and we couldnβt stop. First night in months my phone stayed face down on the counter.
