7 Reasons Couples Who “Know Everything” About Each Other Are Playing Would You Rather Again
By Claire Bennett
Last Updated: —
— a 3-star review of another couples game
REASON 1: YOU THINK YOU KNOW WHAT THEY’D PICK
After enough years, you can finish each other’s sentences. So guess this one. Would they rather win $1 million today, or get $5,000 a month for life? Write your guess down before they answer. You might be surprised, and that’s the fun part.
REASON 2: NO DEEP TALKS. NO THERAPY QUESTIONS.
A lot of couples say question books get heavy fast. This one starts light. Would you rather sneeze glitter or hiccup bubbles? Have a pet duck that follows you everywhere, or a cat that talks but only to complain? You’ll be laughing long before the hard ones.
REASON 3: YOU HAVE TO PICK ONE
That’s the only rule. “Neither” isn’t an answer. “Both” isn’t an answer. “It depends” is definitely not an answer. Then you each say why, and the why is where the good stuff comes out.
REASON 4: THE SPEED ROUNDS DON’T LET YOU THINK
One of you reads twelve fast ones. Coffee or tea. Beach or mountains. Save or spend. One minute for the whole page. Match 8 or more and you both get bonus points. The honest answers come out fast.
REASON 5: KEEP SCORE, OR DON’T
Play just to talk, no pens needed. Or grab two pens. Every matching answer fills a heart for your Us Score, every right guess is a point, and the scoreboard at the back crowns a Choices Champion. The runner-up signs the certificate.
REASON 6: FIVE MINUTES OR A WHOLE EVENING
Nine rounds, from Warm-Up Silly to The Tough Ones, with Food Fights, Getaways and a Throwback round in between. Play one page after dinner or a whole round on a long drive. No setup, no screens.
REASON 7: 30 DAYS. FULL REFUND. NO HOOPS.
Play a week of questions. If you two aren’t laughing, email us within 30 days for a full refund. Keep the book.
Choices & Us — Would You Rather for Two
Choices & Us — Would You Rather for Two
- Would-you-rather questions, from silly to clever
- Guess what your partner picks. It’s harder than it sounds
- Play just for fun, or keep score and crown a winner
Couldn't load pickup availability
Flat $4.95 tracked U.S. shipping.
What’s Inside
What’s Inside
Softcover, 8 × 10 inches.
Would-you-rather questions for every mood: silly, random, clever and unexpected. Speed rounds where there’s no time to think. Rounds where you guess what your partner will pick. Two ways to play: just talk it out, or keep score and see who wins.
How It Works
How It Works
Open to any page. One of you reads the question out loud. Answer fast, or guess what the other one will choose before they say it.
Play for five minutes or the whole evening. On the couch, at the kitchen table, on a road trip. No setup, no screens.
Shipping & Guarantee
Shipping & Guarantee
Most orders arrive in 10–15 business days, anywhere in the U.S. Flat $4.95 tracked shipping.
30-day money-back guarantee: if it doesn’t earn its spot on your coffee table, email us and we refund the full price. Keep the book.
Four pages from the book
One question. Two answers.
Every round has the same four kinds of page. Here’s what each one does.
Every round
Question pages
- Three would-you-rathers on every page.
- Each of you ticks A or B in your own row.
- Same answer? Fill in the heart.
Hearts add up to your Us Score
Every round
Speed Round
- One of you reads, fast. You both circle.
- Twelve quick pairs. One minute for the page.
- Match 8 or more for 2 bonus points each.
No thinking. Just answer.
Every round
Guess My Pick
- Before they answer, write what you think they’ll pick.
- Then they answer out loud.
- Every right guess is 1 point.
Where someone gets cocky
Back of the book
Final Scoreboard
- Add up all nine rounds.
- Count every heart for your Us Score.
- Crown the Choices Champion.
The runner-up signs
Nine rounds. Silly to seriously tough.
Play them in order or jump around. Every round has its own mood.
Guess their pick before you scroll
Six Guess My Pick questions from the book. Write your guess first, then ask.
Food Fights
Guess My Pick
Would you rather give up cheese foreverORgive up ice cream forever?
Guess first. Then ask.
Home & Habits
Guess My Pick
Would you rather give up your phone for a monthORgive up your car for a month?
Guess first. Then ask.
Getaways
Guess My Pick
Would you rather a week anywhere in America, all paidORthree days anywhere in the world, all paid?
Guess first. Then ask.
Sweet on Us
Guess My Pick
Would you rather a day where I do every choreORa night where I plan the whole date?
Guess first. Then ask.
Throwback
Guess My Pick
Would you rather relive the year we metORjump ahead five years?
Guess first. Then ask.
The Tough Ones
Guess My Pick
Would you rather hear what I really think of your cookingORhear what I really think of your driving?
Guess first. Then ask.
Every kind of couple. Every kind of night.
Kitchen table, after dinner
Long-distance, same question
Twenty years married
First apartment
Grandparents’ rematch
Road trip, passenger reads
Same couch. Different night.
Before
Two phones, one couch
After one round
One book, two answers
Before
Same show, third night
After one round
Food Fights, round two
Before
Scrolling in bed
After one round
Speed round, lights still on
The Book By The Numbers
How a Round Goes
Practice round
Three easy ones to learn the boxes. They don’t count. Probably.
- Breakfast for dinner tonight, or dinner for breakfast tomorrow?
- Wear a cape for a whole day, or a crown?
- Go to bed early tonight, or stay up way too late?
Question pages
Read one out. You both pick. Then say why.
- Tick A or B in your own row
- Same answer fills a heart
- Hearts are shared. Nobody wins them
Speed round
One minute. No thinking. Just answer.
- Twelve quick pairs
- You both circle fast
- 8 matches or more = 2 bonus points each
Guess My Pick
Write your guess before they answer. This is the 1 vs 1 part.
- Four questions a round
- 1 point for every right guess
- Then swap
Score box
Add it up at the end of every round and carry it to the back.
- Guess points
- Speed bonus
- Hearts
Crown a winner
The Final Scoreboard crowns the Choices Champion and adds up your Us Score.
- A champion certificate, signed by the runner-up
- A Write Your Own page with six blank boxes
- “150 hearts or more? You two might be the same person.”
It’s not the question. It’s the answer.
Two Phones, One Couch
The night isn’t bad. It’s just quiet. One question changes that.
Somebody Gets Cocky
Three right guesses in a row and the trash talk starts.
The “Why”
The pick takes a second. The reason behind it can take all night.
The Gift That Gets Played
Not a candle. A book you open after dinner.
Dark at Five
Cold nights in, sorted. No setup, no screens.
Your Handwriting
The ticks stay on the page. So does every wrong guess.
Play a week of questions. If you two aren’t laughing, we refund it.
Email us within 30 days for a full refund. Keep the book.
Everything Couples Ask Before They Order
Straight answers — starting with the question everyone actually has.
Is it deep or therapy-style? +
How does the scoring work? +
Do we have to keep score? +
How many questions are there? +
How many players? +
How long does it take? +
Do we need anything else? +
Is any of it explicit? +
How long does shipping take? +
What’s the guarantee? +
Still have a question?
A real person replies to every message — usually within 24 hours.
CONTACT SUPPORT →You’ve been together long enough to guess their answer. Have you?
363 would-you-rathers for the two of you, from silly to seriously tough. Tracked U.S. shipping and 30 days to change your mind.
Tracked U.S. shipping · 30-day money-back guarantee
